A Selection of Artisan Cheese
Crafted with Care, Served with Character
Experience a refined collection of artisan cheeses, thoughtfully selected and cut to order from our local store to your table.
about us
Welcome to Exeter Cheese Co.
At Exeter Cheese Co., we celebrate the art of fine cheese. Our selection brings together exceptional flavors, traditional methods, and carefully sourced ingredients — all chosen with a deep appreciation for quality and craftsmanship.
Whether you visit our store or order online, each piece is prepared to offer a truly memorable experience.
Satisfied Guests
0
K+
Orders Served Fresh
0
k+
Curated Varieties
0
+
A Trusted Local Cheese Shop
our menu
Discover Our Artisan Collection
From rich and matured to soft and delicate, each cheese is chosen to offer a unique and refined taste.
-
Menu
Seasonal Salad
Price range: $6.35 through $12.75 Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page -
Menu
Monarch Mozzarella Sandwich
Price range: $6.35 through $12.75 Select options This product has multiple variants. The options may be chosen on the product page
Student Deal
The Frenchie
Jambon Beurre- a classic french sandwich made on our sourdough baguette, slathered with rich european butter and layered with ham
$7.00
Monarch Mozzarella Sandwich
Sundried tomato aioli, turkey, ham, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and spring mix on focaccia
Price range: $6.35 through $12.75
Seasonal Salad
Spring mix, vinaigrette, candied walnuts, seasonal fruit, and specialty cheese (Optional add on of diced chicken)
Price range: $6.35 through $12.75
The “BLT”
House sauce, bacon, tomato, arugula, farmhouse cheddar and mozzarella on artisan sourdough
$12.75
The Caprese
Basil pesto, marinated tomatoes, balsamic glaze, mozzarella or halloumi cheese on ciabatta
$12.75
our menu
Discover Our Artisan Collection
From rich and matured to soft and delicate, each cheese is chosen to offer a unique and refined taste.
The Original
Farmhouse cheddar and fontina cheese on artisan sourdough
The Caprese
Basil pesto, marinated tomatoes, balsamic glaze, mozzarella or halloumi cheese on ciabatta
The "BLT"
House sauce, bacon, tomato, arugula, farmhouse cheddar and mozzarella on artisan sourdough
Seasonal Salad
Spring mix, vinaigrette, candied walnuts, seasonal fruit, and specialty cheese (Optional add on of diced chicken)
Monarch Mozzarella Sandwich
Sundried tomato aioli, turkey, ham, fresh mozzarella, tomatoes, and spring mix on focaccia
The Frenchie
Jambon Beurre- a classic French sandwich made on our sourdough baguette, slathered with rich European butter and layered with ham
Curated for You
Cheese Boxes & Thoughtful Gifts
Our handcrafted cheese boxes are designed for sharing, celebrating, and gifting.
Each selection is carefully arranged to bring together flavor, texture, and presentation.
Perfect for gatherings, occasions, or simply indulging in something special.
Charcuterie Cup
The perfect on-the-go snack! Filled with various nuts, cubed cheese, salami, seasonal fruit and crackers this snack cup is a fun and easy treat for everyone.
$8
The Aged & Spread Box
The Aged & Spread Box features a variety of Aged and Semi-Firm cheeses, artisan cured meats, fresh fruits, seasonal vegetables, and crunchy nuts. Served with a variety of crackers, jam or honey, cornichons and olives, it’s a well-rounded option for any occasion.
Small Box
$45
Medium Box
$65
Large Box
$85
Event Box
$165
The Monarch Box
The Monarch Box features a variety of semi-firm cheeses, savory cured meats, fresh fruits, seasonal vegetables, and crunchy nuts. It’s served with artisan crackers, jam or honey, cornichons and olives for a smooth, crowd-pleasing spread.
Small Box
$45
Medium Box
$65
Large Box
$85
Event Box
$165
The Cream Cut Box
Featuring a delicious mix of soft-ripened and fresh cheeses, it’s balanced with a refreshing fruit mix, crisp vegetables, classic cured meats, and crunchy nuts. It’s served with an assortment of crackers, jam or honey, cornichons and olives.
Small Box
$45
Medium Box
$65
Large Box
$85
Event Box
$165
Curated for You
Cheese Boxes & Thoughtful Gifts
Our handcrafted cheese boxes are designed for sharing, celebrating, and gifting.
Each selection is carefully arranged to bring together flavor, texture, and presentation.
Perfect for gatherings, occasions, or simply indulging in something special.
The Monarch Box
The Monarch Box features a variety of semi-firm cheeses, savory cured meats, fresh fruits, seasonal vegetables, and crunchy nuts. It’s served with artisan crackers, jam or honey, cornichons and olives for a smooth, crowd-pleasing spread.
Small Box
$45
Medium Box
$65
Large Box
$85
Event Box
$165
The Aged & Spread Box
The Aged & Spread Box features a variety of Aged and Semi-Firm cheeses, artisan cured meats, fresh fruits, seasonal vegetables, and crunchy nuts. Served with a variety of crackers, jam or honey, cornichons and olives, it’s a well-rounded option for any occasion.
Small Box
$45
Medium Box
$65
Large Box
$85
Event Box
$165
The Cream Cut Box
Featuring a delicious mix of soft-ripened and fresh cheeses, it’s balanced with a refreshing fruit mix, crisp vegetables, classic cured meats, and crunchy nuts. It’s served with an assortment of crackers, jam or honey, cornichons and olives.
Small Box
$45
Medium Box
$65
Large Box
$85
Event Box
$165
Our Cheese Varieties
Disclaimer: We do our best to keep our cheeses in stock, but availability may vary due to seasonality and sourcing. If something isn’t available, we’re happy to recommend a delicious alternative!
Cheddars
2 Yr. Aged White Cheddar
Truffle Cheddar
Habanero Cheddar
Goudas
Smoked Gouda
Bacon Gouda
Beemster 18 month Aged Gouda
Double Cream Gouda
Jalapeno Gouda
Hollandia Herb Gouda
Blue Cheeses
Maytag Blue
Bay Blue
Black and Blue Goat Blue
Danish Blue Cheese
Irish Cashel Blue
Local/American Creameries
Asiago
Baby Swiss
Jalapeno Havarti
Jalapeno Pepper Jack
Blanc Gruyere
Smoked Gruyere
Double Cream French Brie
Mike’s Smoked Firehouse Jack Lionza
San Joaquin Gold
Toma
Butter Cheese
Imported Cheeses
Comte
Raclette
Ice Skater
Irish Dubliner
Drunken Goat
Pecorino Romano
Papillon Roquefort
Mustard Beemster
Parmigiano Reggiano
Halloumi Goat Cheese
Plaza De Espana Manchego
Our Services
Explore our wide range of cheese offerings, including artisanal cheeses, cheese platters, and cheese pairing recommendations.
Whether you’re a cheese connoisseur or a newbie, we have something for everyone.
Charcuterie Boxes
Indulge in our exquisite charcuterie boxes, carefully curated with a selection of premium cheeses, fresh fruits, cured meats, nuts, and crackers. Perfect for gatherings, events, or a cozy night in
Pairing Recommendations
Enhance your cheese experience with our expert pairing recommendations. From wines and local honey, to jams, nuts, crackers and more. We’ll help you discover the perfect combinations for your palate
Custom Orders
Looking for something specific? Give us a call and we’ll figure out the best options for your needs. Let us elevate your cheese moments!
Open Hours
- Sunday - Monday
- Closed
- Tuesday - Friday
- 10:00 am – 6:00 pm
- Saturday
- 10:00 am - 3:00 pm
Visit Us
A Cheese Experience, In Store
Step into our shop and explore a world of carefully selected cheeses. Our team is here to guide you through flavors, pairings, and new discoveries.
We invite you to experience the craft, the taste, and the passion behind every selection.
Perfect Pairings
Enhance Your Experience
Complete your table with our selection of fine accompaniments, chosen to complement every cheese.
Artisan crackers
Local honey
Flavored almonds and pistachios
Spread and jams
Wines
A Tradition of Quality & Taste
We take pride in offering cheeses that reflect true craftsmanship. Every selection is made with attention to detail — ensuring quality, freshness, and a taste that speaks for itself.
From our shop to your table, excellence is always at the heart of what we do.
testimonials
Words from Our Customers
frequently asked questions
Helpful Information
Yes, orders can be collected directly from our store.
All cheeses are carefully handled to ensure freshness.